You're curled up on the couch with your four or five year old, reading their favorite storybook together. The main character just lost their beloved toy, and the illustration shows tears streaming down their face. You pause and ask, "How do you think they're feeling?" Your child looks at you blankly. "I don't know," they say, already turning the page. Or maybe they answer, but their response doesn't quite match what's happening in the story. You wonder: Should they understand this by now? Is something wrong?
Let me share something wonderful with you, dear parent. If this sounds familiar, you are not alone, and your child is developing BEAUTIFULLY. What you're witnessing isn't a deficit or a delay. It's actually your child's brain in the middle of one of the most important developmental leaps of early childhood.
In this guide, we'll explore why children ages four to five sometimes struggle to understand character emotions in stories, what the research tells us about this normal developmental phase, and gentle strategies you can use to support your child's growing emotional intelligence. Plus, I'll share a story from The Book of Inara that makes emotions visible and understandable for young minds.
What Is Theory of Mind?
Between ages three and five, children are developing something called theory of mind. This is the cognitive ability to understand that other people have thoughts, feelings, beliefs, and perspectives that are different from their own. It's a HUGE milestone, and it doesn't happen overnight.
Think about it this way. For the first few years of life, your little one experienced the world almost entirely from their own perspective. Everything was about what THEY could see, what THEY could feel, what THEY wanted. And that's exactly how it should be! But now, their brain is starting to make these incredible connections. They're beginning to realize that the character in the story might feel sad for reasons that are completely different from why THEY would feel sad. They're starting to understand that someone else's experience might be totally different from their own.
This is complex cognitive work! Your child is learning to:
- Recognize that others have internal mental states (thoughts and feelings)
- Understand that these mental states can differ from their own
- Connect story events to emotional outcomes
- Identify emotions based on facial expressions and context
- Predict how characters might feel or behave based on their perspective
Research shows that children typically begin acquiring theory of mind around age four, and it continues developing throughout early childhood and beyond. So if your four or five year old is still learning to understand why characters feel certain ways, they're right on track.
Why Storybooks Are Perfect for Building Empathy
Here's what's SO beautiful about this developmental phase: storybooks provide the perfect, safe space for children to practice understanding emotions and perspectives.
Dr. Natalia Kucirkova from University College London has conducted extensive research on how children's storybooks promote empathy. Her work shows that reading stories together supports cognitive empathy through perspective-taking. When children engage with characters who are different from themselves, they're building what researchers call "out-group empathy" - the ability to understand and care about people who aren't like them.
"Children's storybooks could potentially foster cognitive empathy through recognition and response toward in- and out-group members. Ages 2-8 represent a critical window for developing perspective-taking through literature."
— Dr. Natalia Kucirkova, University College London
And here's what's magical: the conversations you have during story time matter EVEN MORE than the story itself. Research demonstrates that parent-child conversational turns during book reading actually predict children's language development and emotional understanding. Every time you pause to ask, "How do you think this character feels?" or "Why do you think they did that?" you're giving your child's brain exactly the practice it needs to grow these skills.
What Research Tells Us About Emotional Understanding
The National Association for the Education of Young Children has published wonderful research on teaching emotional intelligence in early childhood. Their findings emphasize that discussing how storybook characters feel helps children practice applying emotional intelligence in real life.
Here's what we know from the research:
- Emotional vocabulary matters: Read-alouds introduce children to new words for expressing emotions beyond just "happy," "sad," and "mad." Words like "frustrated," "disappointed," "excited," and "worried" help children identify and communicate their own feelings more precisely.
- Recognizing emotion cues is foundational: Learning to identify facial expressions, body language, and situational cues in stories helps children develop the same skills in real-world interactions.
- Emotional intelligence predicts success: Children with higher emotional intelligence are better able to pay attention, more engaged in learning, and have more positive relationships with peers.
- Understanding develops gradually: Theory of mind competence and knowledge of emotions develop together in preschoolers aged 3-4 years, with significant improvements between ages 4-5.
What does this mean for you? It means that when your child struggles to understand why a character feels a certain way, they're not behind. They're actively learning one of life's most complex and important skills.
Gentle Strategies to Support Emotional Understanding
Now that you understand what's happening developmentally, let's talk about how you can gently support your child's growing ability to understand emotions in stories and in life.
1. Pause at Emotional Moments
When you're reading together, pause at moments when characters show strong emotions. You might say something like, "Look at this character's face. What do you notice?" Help your child connect the visual cues - facial expressions, body language, tears, smiles - to the emotions the character might be feeling. This builds their ability to read emotional signals.
2. Ask Open-Ended Questions
Instead of asking yes/no questions like "Is this character sad?" try open-ended questions that invite thinking: "How do you think this character is feeling right now?" And then - this is the magic part - ask "Why?" or "What happened that might have made them feel this way?" These questions help your child practice connecting events to emotions, which is a key component of theory of mind.
3. Connect Stories to Your Child's Experiences
This is SO powerful. When you make connections between the story and your child's own life, you're helping them use their emotional experiences as a bridge to understanding others. You might say, "Remember when you felt worried about starting preschool? I wonder if this character feels the same way about their first day." This validates their feelings while building empathy.
4. Expand Emotional Vocabulary
Go beyond basic emotion words. If a character looks upset, you might say, "I think this character feels disappointed because they really wanted to go to the park, but it's raining." You're teaching the specific word "disappointed" and connecting it to a cause. This rich vocabulary helps children identify and express their own feelings more precisely.
5. Be Patient with the Process
If your child doesn't understand right away, that's OKAY. You can gently explain without making them feel wrong. "I think this character feels sad because their friend moved away. Have you ever missed someone? How did that feel?" You're teaching them how to think about other people's feelings, and that takes time and practice.
6. Model Emotional Awareness
Share your own emotional observations as you read. "Oh, I notice this character's shoulders are slumped and they're looking down. That makes me think they might be feeling sad or discouraged." You're showing your child HOW to observe and interpret emotional cues.
A Story That Can Help
In The Book of Inara, we have a beautiful story that makes emotions visible and understandable for young minds. Let me tell you about it:
The Center Where Hearts Are Heard
Perfect for: Ages 4-5
What makes it special: In this story, Ethan and Sofia visit a magical advocacy center with Grandpa Ravi, and something wonderful happens. Their worried feelings actually bloom into solution flowers! This story beautifully models emotional expression and understanding. When worried feelings transform into visible flowers, children can SEE the process of how expressing emotions leads to understanding and solutions.
Key lesson: The story demonstrates that feelings can be heard, understood, and transformed - exactly what children need to learn about emotional comprehension in stories and in life. When we share our feelings, others can understand what we're experiencing and help us find solutions.
How to use it: After reading this story with your child, you can have rich conversations. Ask: "How do you think Ethan felt when his worries turned into flowers? What does that teach us about sharing our feelings? Can you show me what Ethan's face might have looked like when he was worried?" These questions help your child practice identifying emotions, understanding their causes, and recognizing how feelings can change.
You're Doing Beautifully
The Magic Book whispers something important to me, and I want to share it with you: Your child is learning one of life's most complex and beautiful skills - understanding that other minds work differently than their own. This takes time. It takes practice. It takes gentle guidance from someone who loves them deeply, someone exactly like you.
Every single time you read together and talk about feelings, you're providing that guidance. Every question you ask, every connection you make, every moment you pause to wonder together about why a character feels a certain way - all of this is building your child's capacity for empathy, for understanding, for connecting with others.
Some four year olds grasp complex emotions quickly. Others need more time and practice. Both paths are beautiful. Both are exactly right for that child. Your job isn't to rush this development or worry that your child isn't "getting it" fast enough. Your job is to provide a safe, loving space where your child can explore feelings through stories, ask questions without judgment, and gradually build their understanding at their own perfect pace.
And here's what's truly wonderful: this skill of understanding emotions in stories directly translates to understanding emotions in real life. When your child learns to recognize that a character feels sad because they lost their favorite toy, they're also learning to recognize when their friend at preschool feels sad for the same reason. When they practice thinking about why a character made a certain choice, they're building the foundation for empathy, for kindness, for all those beautiful qualities we hope to see in our children as they grow.
So keep reading together, wonderful parent. Keep talking about feelings. Keep asking those beautiful questions. Keep making connections between stories and your child's own experiences. And trust - truly trust - that your child's brain is developing exactly as it should, in exactly the right timing, with exactly the right guide: you.
With love and starlight,
Inara
Related Articles
- When Your Child Plays Too Rough: Teaching Boundaries with Empathy (Ages 4-5)
- Understanding Your Child's Developing Empathy: A Guide to Perspective-Taking in 4-5 Year Olds
- How Your 4-5 Year Old Learns Empathy: The Beautiful Science of Caring
- How Children Ages 4-5 Develop Advanced Empathy and Perspective-Taking
- When Your Child Struggles to Celebrate Others (What's Really Happening)
Show transcript
Hello, wonderful parent! It's me, Inara, and I am so happy you're here today. You know, the Magic Book and I have been hearing from so many parents lately who are wondering about something really important. They're noticing that when they read stories with their four or five year old, their child sometimes doesn't quite understand why the characters feel certain ways. And I want you to know something right from the start. If this sounds familiar, you are not alone, and your child is developing BEAUTIFULLY.
Let me share something wonderful with you. What you're seeing isn't a problem at all. It's actually your child's brain growing in the most amazing way! Between ages three and five, children are developing something called theory of mind. That's a fancy way of saying they're learning to understand that other people have different thoughts, feelings, and perspectives from their own. And this is HUGE! This is one of the most important developmental milestones of early childhood.
Think about it this way. For the first few years of life, your little one experienced the world mostly from their own perspective. Everything was about what THEY could see, what THEY could feel, what THEY wanted. And that's exactly how it should be! But now, around age four or five, their brain is starting to make these incredible connections. They're beginning to realize that the character in the story might feel sad for reasons that are different from why THEY would feel sad. They're starting to understand that someone else's experience might be completely different from their own.
The research on this is so beautiful. Dr. Natalia Kucirkova from University College London explains that storybooks are actually one of the BEST tools for helping children develop this cognitive empathy. When you read together and talk about how characters feel, you're giving your child's brain exactly the practice it needs to grow these skills. Every time you ask, how do you think this character feels, or why do you think they're sad, you're helping build those neural pathways that support emotional understanding.
And here's something else that's really important to know. The conversations you have during story time matter SO much. Research shows that parent-child conversational turns during book reading actually predict language development and emotional understanding. So when you pause to talk about feelings, when you wonder together about why a character made a certain choice, when you connect the story to your child's own experiences, you're doing exactly what they need.
Now, I know sometimes it can feel frustrating when you're trying to help your child understand a story and they just don't seem to get it. Maybe you're reading about a character who's feeling lonely, and your child says, but why? Or maybe they can't quite grasp why the character in the story is scared of something that doesn't scare them. And in those moments, it's so easy to worry. Is my child developing okay? Should they understand this by now?
Let me tell you what the Magic Book whispers to me about this. Your child is learning one of life's most complex skills, understanding that other minds work differently than their own. This takes TIME. It takes practice. It takes gentle guidance from someone who loves them, someone exactly like you. And the beautiful thing is, every single time you read together and talk about feelings, you're providing that guidance.
Here are some wonderful ways you can support this learning. First, when you're reading together, pause at moments when characters show strong emotions. You might say something like, look at this character's face. What do you notice? Help your child connect the visual cues, like facial expressions or body language, to the emotions the character might be feeling.
Second, ask open-ended questions that invite your child to think about the character's perspective. Instead of asking, is this character sad, you might ask, how do you think this character is feeling right now? And then, this is the magic part, ask why. What happened in the story that might have made them feel this way? These questions help your child practice the skill of connecting events to emotions.
Third, and this is so important, connect the story to your child's own experiences. You might say, remember when you felt worried about starting preschool? I wonder if this character feels the same way about their first day. When you make these connections, you're helping your child use their own emotional experiences as a bridge to understanding others.
And fourth, be patient with the process. If your child doesn't understand right away, that's OKAY. You can gently explain. You might say, I think this character feels sad because their friend moved away. Have you ever missed someone? How did that feel? You're teaching them the vocabulary of emotions and showing them how to think about other people's feelings.
Now, let me tell you about a story that can really help with this. In The Book of Inara, we have a beautiful tale called The Center Where Hearts Are Heard. In this story, Ethan and Sofia visit a magical advocacy center with Grandpa Ravi, and something wonderful happens. Their worried feelings actually bloom into solution flowers! Can you imagine?
What makes this story so special for helping children understand emotions is that it shows feelings in a concrete, visible way. When Ethan and Sofia express their worries and those worries transform into flowers, children can SEE the process of emotional expression and understanding. The story demonstrates that when we share our feelings, others can hear them, understand them, and help us find solutions.
After you read this story with your child, you can have such rich conversations. You might ask, how do you think Ethan felt when his worries turned into flowers? What does that teach us about sharing our feelings? Can you show me what Ethan's face might have looked like when he was worried? These questions help your child practice the very skills you're nurturing, identifying emotions, understanding their causes, and recognizing how feelings can change.
The Magic Book also reminds me that children learn emotional understanding at different paces, and that's perfectly normal. Some four year olds might grasp complex emotions quickly, while others need more time and practice. Both paths are beautiful. Both are exactly right for that child. Your job isn't to rush this development. Your job is to provide a safe, loving space where your child can explore feelings through stories, ask questions, and gradually build their understanding.
And here's something else that's really encouraging. Research from the National Association for the Education of Young Children shows that children with higher emotional intelligence, which includes understanding emotions in themselves and others, are better able to pay attention, more engaged in learning, and have more positive relationships. So every conversation you have about story characters' feelings is actually supporting your child's success in so many areas of life.
I also want you to know that this skill of understanding emotions in stories directly translates to understanding emotions in real life. When your child learns to recognize that a character feels sad because they lost their favorite toy, they're also learning to recognize when their friend at preschool feels sad for the same reason. When they practice thinking about why a character made a certain choice, they're building the foundation for empathy, for kindness, for all those beautiful qualities we hope to see in our children.
So if your little one is still learning to understand why characters feel certain ways, celebrate that learning! Every question they ask, every time they look confused about a character's emotions, that's their brain actively working to build these new skills. And with your patient guidance, with rich conversations during story time, with stories like The Center Where Hearts Are Heard that make emotions visible and understandable, they WILL get there.
The Magic Book and I believe in you, wonderful parent. We believe in your child. This journey of emotional understanding is one of the most beautiful parts of growing up, and you're providing exactly the support your child needs. Keep reading together. Keep talking about feelings. Keep asking those wonderful questions. And trust that your child's brain is developing exactly as it should.
You can find The Center Where Hearts Are Heard and so many other stories that support emotional learning in The Book of Inara app. Each story is crafted with love to help children understand themselves and others better.
Thank you for being here today, for caring so deeply about your child's development, and for giving them the gift of stories and conversation. You're doing something truly wonderful.
With love and starlight, Inara.
